Blog ·

Teaching children the real consequences of their actions

I have been assisting a school in writing a new behaviour policy. In preparation for this journey I completed an online behaviour course with Paul Dix (opens in a new tab); it was life changing, not only for the school in question but unexpectedly it had a profound impact on my parenting.

Since my eldest was able to argue back or refuse to do things (around age 2) I have used consequences as a means to manage his behaviour. I always threatened to take a toy away or remove something he was looking forward to “if you don’t help me tidy up your bedroom I will have to take your blue dinosaur away”. It always worked. Of course it did. I was manipulating his behaviour.

What I was doing wasn’t out of neglect or a lack of love for my child - I wanted him to learn to help, learn to listen and be kind - this was just the response I had acquired, it seemed to be effective and made my life as a parent manageable. What I didn’t realise, was that I wasn’t teaching him the real consequences of his actions.

Following my behaviour course, my partner and I reflected on our approach and decided that we would remove the current consequences in place. My son (now 7) was joyous with this new trial, smiling like a cheshire cat he walked around feeling powerful. I, on the other hand, was terrified; I felt vulnerable and was worried that I’d lose a sense of control.

It wasn’t long after making this decision (a few minutes!) that I was faced with the first (of many) challenges. He didn’t want to tidy up before bedtime and was refusing. A familiar situation for us all, but now we didn’t have the usual tools to try and manipulate him into complying. Knowing this, his response was “I’m not going to tidy up and you can’t do anything because there are no consequences anymore.”

I could feel a bit of panic setting in—my partner looked at me, I looked at him, and we quietly stepped aside for a quick chat. A mini meeting helped us confirm that, yes, there were no physical consequences (like removing toys), but we agreed that there were always consequences in life, even if they weren’t as clear-cut.

We decided to keep it simple. Instead of focusing on what he “should” be feeling, we just acknowledged the situation: “Tidying up together helps the house feel calmer, and when things get left out, it can feel a little more chaotic.” He just shrugged and said, “I’m not tidying up,” and walked off. We were left feeling unsure, but we didn’t push it further. We continued tidying up ourselves, just quietly going about our tasks. There was no pressure for him to act a certain way, just a shared understanding that the energy in the room had shifted.

This response went on for a few weeks - we kept at it, despite our apprehension - a cycle of his refusal, followed by us carrying on as normal. Then in week 4, something magical happened - he suddenly began demonstrating the skill to predict the natural consequences of his actions, adapting and managing his own behaviour. The hard work had paid off; he was no longer behaving in order to keep his toys but was behaving as he didn’t enjoy the feeling he had when others were picking up his mess or feeling stressed as they were rushed for time - he had learned such a valuable lesson.

I can’t say it’s been an easy journey but now we are in a place where he truly understands the consequences of his actions, his place in the world and the power he has to be part of creating positive and collaborative experiences.

It can feel much easier (and quicker) to manipulate a child’s behaviour - it provides a quick fix to complex situations and can get us out of some very tricky situations but in the long term it is important for children to truly understand what comes of working as a team, being kind and listening to one another.

It’s important to reflect upon our approach to this in schools too - handing out extrinsic rewards such as stickers and small toys and punishments such as removing play times or golden time isn’t really forcing our children to think about the effect their behaviour is having on others. It may take more time (and time is of course something us teachers struggle to find) but once embedded, this approach could have a profound effect on connection, understanding, empathy and overall wellbeing of staff and children. I think it is highly important that settings explore their use of reward systems and reflect on what learning is taking place when these moments arise.